• Business
  • Life
  • Celebrity
  • Sport
  • Blog
  • Auto
  • Tech
Stories from SWNS
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
    Living The Fantasy: An Interview With The Serpent Calls Author Christopher Bramley

    Living The Fantasy: An Interview With The Serpent Calls Author Christopher Bramley

    Sharp As A Razor: An Interview With Atheist Author Harry Margulies

    Sharp As A Razor: An Interview With Atheist Author Harry Margulies

    Karim Tahseen Khayat: Seeds Training Services and Digital Services

    Dig into Temporarily Insane by Carl Borgen

    Dig into Temporarily Insane by Carl Borgen

    From HID to LED

    From HID to LED

    Dying woman granted final wish to be reunited with her beloved horse and pet dogs one last time

    Dying woman granted final wish to be reunited with her beloved horse and pet dogs one last time

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Business
  • Life
    • Celebrity
  • Tech
    Artificial Intelligence and Online Casino Games

    Artificial Intelligence and Online Casino Games

    What are the Latest Digital Marketing Trends?

    What are the Latest Digital Marketing Trends?

    Improve Your Financial Prospects With a Forex Trading Course

    Improve Your Financial Prospects With a Forex Trading Course

    Adsterra Malware Protection: How Does Adware Work?

    Adsterra Malware Protection: How Does Adware Work?

    How to Sell Your Online Store for Maximum Profit

    How to Sell Your Online Store for Maximum Profit

    From HID to LED

    From HID to LED

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
  • Review

    The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild gameplay on the Nintendo Switch

    Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun Review

    macOS Sierra review: Mac users get a modest update this year

    Hands on: Samsung Galaxy A5 2017 review

    The Last Guardian Playstation 4 Game review

    Intel Core i7-7700K ‘Kaby Lake’ review

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    Living The Fantasy: An Interview With The Serpent Calls Author Christopher Bramley

    Living The Fantasy: An Interview With The Serpent Calls Author Christopher Bramley

    Sharp As A Razor: An Interview With Atheist Author Harry Margulies

    Sharp As A Razor: An Interview With Atheist Author Harry Margulies

    Karim Tahseen Khayat: Seeds Training Services and Digital Services

    Dig into Temporarily Insane by Carl Borgen

    Dig into Temporarily Insane by Carl Borgen

    From HID to LED

    From HID to LED

    Dying woman granted final wish to be reunited with her beloved horse and pet dogs one last time

    Dying woman granted final wish to be reunited with her beloved horse and pet dogs one last time

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Business
  • Life
    • Celebrity
  • Tech
    Artificial Intelligence and Online Casino Games

    Artificial Intelligence and Online Casino Games

    What are the Latest Digital Marketing Trends?

    What are the Latest Digital Marketing Trends?

    Improve Your Financial Prospects With a Forex Trading Course

    Improve Your Financial Prospects With a Forex Trading Course

    Adsterra Malware Protection: How Does Adware Work?

    Adsterra Malware Protection: How Does Adware Work?

    How to Sell Your Online Store for Maximum Profit

    How to Sell Your Online Store for Maximum Profit

    From HID to LED

    From HID to LED

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
  • Review

    The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild gameplay on the Nintendo Switch

    Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun Review

    macOS Sierra review: Mac users get a modest update this year

    Hands on: Samsung Galaxy A5 2017 review

    The Last Guardian Playstation 4 Game review

    Intel Core i7-7700K ‘Kaby Lake’ review

No Result
View All Result
Stories from SWNS
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Drunk grandmother let toddler drown in garden pond… but avoids jail after ‘lenient’ sentence

by
August 30, 2013
in News
4
0
SHARES
35
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Child abuse groups condemned a ‘lenient’ judge today after the parents and grandmother of a toddler who drowned in a garden pond escaped jail – despite admitting neglect.

Neglected child drowns in family pond yet parents avoid jail

Tragic Daniel Rees-Smith, aged two, was discovered face down a pond at the home of his alcoholic grandmother Hilary Rees in June last year.

But Rees, 44, who was babysitting little Daniel, had slipped into a drunken stupor – found to be three-times the drink drive limit – on the sofa after guzzling cider and anti-depressants.

Daniel’s parents, Charlotte Rees-Smith, 20, and Andrew Marshall, 22, returned from an evening drinking at a nearby pub to find Daniel dead in the pond.

The house was in a squalid condition with animal faeces, both cat and dog excrement on the floors, was full of flies and littered with rubbish and items of clothing, dirty plates etc.

Bristol Crown Court heard Hilary Rees told police: ”It’s my fault – I have killed my grandson. I was meant to be looking after him”.

All three admitted charges of neglect after a court heard that Daniel was left alone with his boozed-up grandmother in her squalid home in Hanham, Bristol, up to four times a week.

She was found to regularly fall unconscious on the sofa – leaving Daniel to wander alone – and admitted growing cannabis plants in the loft of her foul smelling house.

The defendants were handed suspended jail terms after His Honour Judge Maddison told them that losing little Daniel had already given them a ”heavy burden” to carry.

Manslaughter charges against the trio were also dropped.

But the lenient sentences were slammed by child abuse groups, who claimed judges were not taking the issue seriously enough.

Peter Saunders, founder of The National Association for People Abused in Childhood (NAPAC) said: ”This is another example of an horrendous human tragedy.

”Once again a child has died basically at the neglect of his parents and another carer, in this case the grandmother, and they have walked free.

”This indicates that the judicial system does not take child abuse and neglect seriously enough.

”If a person is convicted for defrauding money they can go to prison for seven or eight years but if a child dies then people go free.

”We make excuses for these people, and if they are an alcoholic then it is a tragedy, but it is too late for these children.

”This wasn’t a momentary lapse of concentration – it was systematic abuse.”

Rupert Lowe, prosecuting, described the house as littered with cat and dog faeces, foul smelling and infested with flies.

He said: ”Hilary Rees has had serious alcohol concerns for many years. She was often found unconscious and it was difficult to raise her.

”When she was woken she often became aggressive and confrontational.

”The whole place was foul-smelling and infested with flies. The garden gate did not lock and, most importantly of all, the pond was unfenced.”

On the evening of June 4, last year the three defendants had gone to the Cross Keys pub near Ms Rees’s Hanham home, before she returned with Daniel to look after him.

She had drunk at least three pints of cider, mixed with anti-depressants, and had fallen asleep on the sofa.

Rees-Smith and Marshall returned at 10.30pm to find Daniel lying dead, face down in the garden pond.

Rees and Rees-Smith admitted child neglect between April 2009 and June 4 2010 and was handed a 12-month jail term suspended for two years and a two year supervision order.

Rees-Smith was given 32 weeks in prison suspended for two years and two years supervision.

Marshall was sentenced to 18 weeks suspended for two years and two years supervision after he admitted the same offence relating to the night of his son’s death.

Judge Maddison said: ”You Hilary Rees and Charlotte Rees-Smith are to be sentenced for neglecting Daniel for a period of about 14 months.

”During that period, you Charlotte Rees-Smith, Daniel’s mum, allowed him to be looked after by your own mother – knowing that she would often be doing so in conditions of considerable squalor.

”And when she had often been incapable of looking after him properly because of the amount of alcohol she had taken.

”That is what did happen. You (Rees) fell asleep in a condition which could be described as a stupor.

”It was a wholly inadequate was of looking after a child. You two (Rees and Rees-Smith) should be deeply ashamed of your behaviour.

”I have read that you are carrying heavy burdens of guilt and will carry them for many years to come – almost certainly for the rest of your lives.”

All three refused to comment when leaving court.

Bristol City Council, in a serious case review of Daniel’s death, revealed no checks had been made by any agency to find out if any adult in sole charge of the tot was misusing alcohol.

But it defended its conduct – stating that it was difficult to conclude whether Daniel’s death was predictable.

Professor Ray Jones, chair of Bristol Safeguarding Children Board, said: ”The death of Daniel was a tragic and sad event and I would like to offer my condolences to the family.

”We accept all the recommendations in the report and one of the first steps for the Bristol board will be to revise and promote our guidance on working with families with drug or alcohol problems to ensure it is fully embedded.

”All agencies involved have agreed an action plan to ensure that the lessons learnt will inform future practice, helping to protect children in Bristol.”

It is never too late for anyone addicted to alcohol. One can always seek help from an alcohol intervention professional.

Tags: Crime
Previous Post

Mother duck lays her eggs at the top of a 12ft pole

Next Post

At lash! Smoker quits after one million cigarettes (He’s smoked 100 a day since he was 11)

Next Post

At lash! Smoker quits after one million cigarettes (He's smoked 100 a day since he was 11)

Comments 4

  1. Our Pray Is That This Site Is says:
    11 years ago

    This is a national disgrace, shame on the judge, I pray he will be able to sleep at night

    Reply
  2. Our Pray Is That This Site Is says:
    11 years ago

    The people who have jobs and earning a living is not doing their job. Why not give up your job to someone who is willing to do their job, but do it right. Letting 3 adults go for manslaughter is an outrage.

    Reply
  3. jack says:
    11 years ago

    and the aprenst of the child left him with his Gran . Isn’t that a responsible thing to do ? Isn’t their fault that Gran got drunk and passed out.. The Gran was at fault here and yes should be locked up ..
    but lets not forget , the Mc Canns actually left their 3  children in an unlocked apartment and went out for a jolly . Yes they checked on the children but we all know how quickly disasters can happen and seperating the Mc Canns from their children  was SWIMMING POOL .. Who was prosecuted for neglect when Maddie when missing  ?? double standard here I think

    Reply
  4. Gally says:
    11 years ago

    I honestly cannot say from this article whether or not the judge’s sentence was adequate, do I know what kind of guilt the parents and grandma are going through? not from what I read. I know that alcoholism ruins lives, alcohol is terrible. Everybody makes mistakes, people like them aren’t as rare as anyone might think. Whether or not they deserve a harsher sentence in the end is up to the Judge, not the child abuse groups.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Gally Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay Connected test

  • 111 Followers
  • 60k Followers
  • 168k Subscribers
  • 23.5k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Women love cheesy chat up lines, a study has revealed

Top 20 cheesy chat-up lines ladies really love

March 5, 2014
The top ten most well-known bingo phrases

The top ten most well-known bingo phrases

January 21, 2014
The horses thunder towards a jump at the Grand National

Amazing racehorse names which never made it

April 23, 2014
HGH Injections Brands: Which Ones Are Best?

HGH Injections Brands: Which Ones Are Best?

January 14, 2019
Chris Fear, 33, outside the Coral betting shop which is refusing to pay out on his 485/1 winning bet

Boycott Coral! Bookmaker faces protest after refusing to pay out on a football fan’s 485/1 bet

184
Women love cheesy chat up lines, a study has revealed

Top 20 cheesy chat-up lines ladies really love

147
Women feel invisible to the opposite sex at the age of 51, researchers found

Women begin feeling invisible to men ‘when they turn 51’

138
UKIP candidate claims Jews murdered each other in the Holocaust in masterplan to create State of Israel

UKIP candidate claims Jews murdered each other in the Holocaust in masterplan to create State of Israel

105
Living and Working in a Small Canadian Town Like Banff

Living and Working in a Small Canadian Town Like Banff

May 13, 2022
Top 5 risks of addressable media advertising

Top 5 risks of addressable media advertising

May 6, 2022
The top 5 UK shopping centres with the highest footfall (and how this can help your business)

The top 5 UK shopping centres with the highest footfall (and how this can help your business)

May 4, 2022
How to build customer relationships and increase loyalty

How to build customer relationships and increase loyalty

May 4, 2022

Recent News

Living and Working in a Small Canadian Town Like Banff

Living and Working in a Small Canadian Town Like Banff

May 13, 2022
Top 5 risks of addressable media advertising

Top 5 risks of addressable media advertising

May 6, 2022
The top 5 UK shopping centres with the highest footfall (and how this can help your business)

The top 5 UK shopping centres with the highest footfall (and how this can help your business)

May 4, 2022
How to build customer relationships and increase loyalty

How to build customer relationships and increase loyalty

May 4, 2022
SWNS

SWNS all rights reserved. Copyright 2020

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Auto
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Celebrity
  • Gaming
  • Life
  • Lifestyle
  • News
  • Pictures
  • Property
  • Review
  • Sport
  • SWNS
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized

Recent News

Living and Working in a Small Canadian Town Like Banff

Living and Working in a Small Canadian Town Like Banff

May 13, 2022
Top 5 risks of addressable media advertising

Top 5 risks of addressable media advertising

May 6, 2022
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Real Fix is a trading style of South West News Service Limited.
Copyright © 2020 South West News Service Limited.

No Result
View All Result
  • Business
  • Life
  • Celebrity
  • Sport
  • Blog
  • Auto
  • Tech

Real Fix is a trading style of South West News Service Limited.
Copyright © 2020 South West News Service Limited.